Academic Reading · Evaluating claims about urban shade
Students distinguish claims that agree with the passage, claims that contradict it and claims the passage leaves unconfirmed.
Teacher plan
40 minutes in class, including 12 minutes of practice.
- Introduce the three labels (6 min)
Put True, False and Not Given on the board. Ask students how a contradiction differs from a missing detail.
- Identify the scope of a claim (7 min)
Use a separate example: a study measured two streets. The claim that it measured four contradicts the example. The claim that it used digital thermometers cannot be checked from that sentence.
- Read and answer (12 min)
Ask students to read the passage and answer all six questions independently. Have them mark the sentence that supports each True or False answer.
- Compare the evidence (10 min)
Pair students and ask them to justify one answer of each type. Open the answer key and compare the wording of the statements with the relevant parts of the passage.
- Revise one decision (5 min)
Have students turn one False statement into a True statement while keeping its subject. Review which words in the original made it inaccurate.
Student task
12 minutes · 6 True / False / Not Given questions
Read the passage about a study of shade at bus stops.
Measuring shade where people wait
A council wanted to find out whether shade arrived where and when passengers needed it. Researchers selected twelve bus stops on two streets with similar buildings. Over six summer weeks, they visited the stops between noon and four in the afternoon. They recorded the air temperature and noted which parts of each waiting area were shaded. As the survey took place in daylight, it did not provide evidence about conditions after sunset.
In the early afternoon, trees on the west side of one street cast shadows across the pavement next to several shelters. At some stops, however, the shadow missed the seats. The researchers found lower surface temperatures on shaded seats than on seats in full sun, but the air temperature at the two types of stop was similar. The study therefore distinguished the temperature of the surfaces passengers touched from the temperature of the air around them.
The team interviewed passengers at four of the twelve stops. Several passengers said they stood outside a shelter to stay in the shade, even when a seat was available. The report recommended mapping the path of shadows before moving a bench or planting a tree. It did not recommend a single shelter design for every location because street orientation and nearby buildings affected the direction of shade.
The council used the results to plan a small trial. At two stops it moved existing benches into areas that received shade when the stops were busiest. A later survey will compare how often people sit at those stops before and after the change. The research team stressed that the first study had measured conditions and recorded passenger comments, while the trial would test whether changing the position of a bench altered behaviour.
For each statement, write True if it agrees with the passage, False if it contradicts the passage, or Not Given if the passage does not provide enough information.
- The researchers collected measurements after sunset.
- Some shadows from trees failed to reach the seats.
- Seats exposed to full sun were warmer at the surface than shaded seats.
- The researchers offered passengers a voucher for taking part in interviews.
- The report recommended the same shelter design for all sites.
- The council paid an outside contractor to move the benches.
Answer key and feedback
Show answer key
- False
Measurements took place between noon and four. The study provides no evidence about conditions after sunset.
- True
The second paragraph says the shadow missed the seats at some stops.
- True
The researchers measured lower surface temperatures on shaded seats.
- Not Given
The passage mentions the interviews but provides no information about vouchers.
- False
The report explicitly rejected a single design for every location.
- Not Given
The passage says the council moved two benches but does not identify who carried out the work or whether anyone was paid.
- Evidence
- Each True or False answer should be supported by a specific part of the passage. For Not Given, identify the missing information.
- Scope
- Check limiting words such as all, some and after. A claim can change meaning even when it repeats most of the passage’s vocabulary.